Protect the Self is listed as the third pillar of the UNREDUCED framework, but in some ways, it may be the most important, and certainly the one we return to again and again as we explore the other pillars.
We’ve talked about how, although the framework is described in a linear fashion, from Name the Constraint to Expand the Field, Protect the Self, and Resist Reduction, in our lives we frequently find ourselves returning through that cycle, sometimes because of the same constraint and sometimes because of new constraints we encounter along the way. And even though accurately naming a constraint is important to understanding what we’re facing, and expanding the field allows us to discover possibilities within or alongside that constraint, I think it’s really the desire to protect the self, in some form or fashion, that drives all four pillars.
By protecting the self, I’m not talking about always putting ourselves first or simply practicing self-care. I’m talking about protecting the person we used to be, the person we are today beyond whatever roles or circumstances may be constraining us, and perhaps most importantly, protecting the person we might yet become. But sometimes the expectations of other people, institutions, and society become part of how we understand ourselves, and we begin limiting ourselves long before we recognize that we’ve done so.
That’s what I learned when I first bumped up against what I would eventually call Name the Constraint. Because I had spent a lot of time believing that the constraint that had narrowed my life was the responsibility I carried, not only for work but for family, as a sole breadwinner, as the sole caregiver for my elderly mom, as a reliable employee, as a good friend, as someone who could be counted on to be there when times got tough. I admit, I guess I prided myself on the ability to carry all those roles. But when they became too heavy, my instinct was to turn to the external forces that kept me in those roles. Or, if I can be a little harsh with myself, to blame the people around me for the minimization of my own life and the curtailing of my own freedom.
And it was when I started to truly look at my circumstances, examine my beliefs, and consider the story I was telling myself that I realized it wasn’t simply other people who had put me in those roles or curtailed my ability to be all that I am. I had participated in that reduction myself, through my beliefs about what made me a good person and what was important for me to contribute, and my own minimization of what mattered to me and what I might contribute to myself and the world if I allowed myself to be my full self.
So for me, naming the constraint opened a window of understanding that led me to expanding the field, which I’ve talked about before, and to rediscovering my creative impulses and all the wonderful “places” my life has taken me in the last year. But what started that journey was the realization that I had shrunk to the point that I didn’t know who I was anymore, and the overwhelming urge to rediscover myself, to reclaim the person I had been while discovering who I might yet become.
That’s why Protect the Self, even though it comes third in the framework I’ve created, is the foundational understanding that led me through the other pillars.
So why do we let roles overtake us? Truly, what is the danger of becoming our role or our multiple roles, especially if those are roles that we’ve chosen and that we enjoy? We all carry many roles, and often they have meaning to us; some roles are chosen freely, while others are carried because of a sense of obligation. But regardless of which roles or how many roles we carry, and regardless of whether they were freely chosen or were a necessity, they don’t represent the entirety of who we are. The problem is that sometimes the role overtakes the person, and it happens so gradually that we don’t even recognize it. No one needs to explicitly ask us to allow this to happen, although sometimes they do. We can easily begin doing it to ourselves, until we begin to identify ourselves only through those roles.
There are some questions we can ask ourselves to help recognize when this is happening:
How and when did the responsibilities that we carry become our entire identity? At what point do we change from saying this is what my life requires right now to saying this is who I am? Importantly, have we begun to measure ourselves and our worth by how well we perform a particular role? Has it become too large a part of our self-definition? Are external expectations causing us to become absorbed in the role, or have we also begun internalizing those expectations? And if it’s a role that we chose, something that’s incredibly meaningful to us, can it still become too large a part of our self-definition? Can it still become something damaging to us?
Because it’s important to understand, if we’re protecting the self, what it is that we’re actually protecting. Oftentimes when we begin to feel constrained by our circumstances, we push back and try to protect or recover who we believe ourselves to be. And that’s certainly a valid ambition. But I believe that protecting the self isn’t about protecting some fixed vision of who we are or preserving exactly who we were before we became overwhelmed by our constraints. I would say it’s more about protecting our ability to continue growing and developing, because we may not be able to go back to the person we were. And maybe that’s okay. What matters is that we preserve our ability to continue becoming.
Oftentimes what happens when we go through this process is that we realize some of our core capacities or characteristics still remain, but need to be expressed in a different way. Or perhaps we want to express them differently based on what we’re discovering about ourselves and our circumstances. In a way, protecting the self is about maintaining a sense of continuity between who we were, who we are, and who we’re becoming, without requiring those versions of ourselves to remain the same. And in the best possible circumstances, perhaps protecting the self is really more about discovering the self, rediscovering the self, or continuing to discover the self.
Recognizing that need and wanting to make room for expansion doesn’t eliminate responsibility. Just because we’ve started to discover or rediscover ourselves doesn’t mean our circumstances have changed or that the possibility of reduction has disappeared. What makes Protect the Self so important is the realization that once we’ve started making room for ourselves within our circumstances, we haven’t accomplished a one-time goal. Making that room is an ongoing commitment. Creating the possibility of growth is not the same thing as sustaining the possibility for growth.
In my own life, rediscovering my creativity and curiosity opened possibilities I hadn’t considered, including the realization that those characteristics could take me in new directions without actually taking me out of my house. But that discovery didn’t eliminate my caregiving obligations or the other responsibilities I carry. When I realized that I could take my creativity and my love of travel and channel them into activities closer to home, what I essentially did was create a new path for myself. But having created it, I needed to maintain the opportunity to continue moving along it.
In my Stepping Into the Unknown essay, I talked about desire paths as described by David Farrier. When we’re expanding the field, sometimes we discover possibilities that were already there but that we simply hadn’t seen before. And sometimes we create possibilities by moving, by taking action. But taking that first step doesn’t guarantee that we’ll be able to keep stepping. Protecting the self largely means protecting that room for continued exploration, development, and change. An important question to ask ourselves here is how do we keep that new possibility, that new discovery, that new passion or creative idea from becoming just another thing we once tried but couldn’t sustain?
Recognizing that we’ve allowed ourselves to become reduced doesn’t mean we won’t find ourselves becoming reduced again. And that’s why we return to the same questions, the same desire to protect ourselves, and the same steps of the framework. But perhaps each time we do, we become a little more aware of when we’ve started to surrender parts of ourselves again. And perhaps it becomes a little easier to recognize what’s happening and find our way back.
I also don’t mean to suggest that it’s easy for everyone to find the time or space to protect the self. In my case, I was fortunate to have a few hours a week and the resources to pursue other interests during that time. Everyone’s roles and responsibilities are different, and so is their capacity to make room for themselves within those circumstances. Sometimes responsibilities really do consume nearly everything we have available to us. Sometimes there simply isn’t an immediately workable solution. Protecting the self doesn’t guarantee that we’ll regain our freedom or find some ideal balance, much less escape difficult circumstances. But the absence of an immediate resolution doesn’t mean that the person living within those circumstances no longer matters.
I do want to briefly talk about the bridge between Protect the Self and the final pillar of UNREDUCED, Resist Reduction. Protect the Self concerns creating and maintaining our capacity for continued discovery and growth, while Resist Reduction concerns what happens when other people, institutions, expectations, or systems try to define us by a particular role or set of roles. Those external definitions can reinforce or reestablish our own reduction, sometimes without our even recognizing it. That’s one reason we may find ourselves returning to Protect the Self, and why none of the pillars stands entirely apart from the others. Sometimes protecting the self privately isn’t sufficient. Sometimes we must also protect ourselves from external reduction.
So I’ll leave you with this thought for now. Protecting the self is largely about preserving the distinction between what life requires of us and who we are. And once we’ve begun making room for ourselves within those circumstances, we need to continue protecting that space and the possibilities it allows us to explore.
So I ask you this:
What part of yourself have you allowed to disappear behind a role? And if you’ve begun to reclaim that part of yourself, what part of that now needs protecting?
Published 14 November 2026 - UNREDUCED™ Pillar Three